Arizona Commission on Judicial Performance Review > Judicial Performance Reports > 2010 Judicial Performance Reports

Home 2010 Judicial Performance Reports

2010 Judicial Performance Reports

ALL Reports

Judge	Commission Vote	Judicial Report	Assignment/Bench	Serving Since
Aceto, Mark F. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Juvenile)	1995
Anderson, Aimee L. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Juvenile)	2007
Anderson, Arthur T. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	1999
Barker, Daniel A. Full Bio Decisions	Meets JPR Standards	View	Appeals Div. I	2001
Barton, Janet E. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	2000
Bassett, Edward W. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Family)	2008
Berch, Rebecca White Full Bio Decisions	Meets JPR Standards	View	Supreme Court	2002
Bergin, Dawn M. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Juvenile)	2007
Borek, Ted B. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Pima (Civil)	2000
Brodman, Roger E. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Juvenile)	2007
Brotherton, William L. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Family)	2007
Brown, Michael J. Full Bio Decisions	Meets JPR Standards	View	Appeals Div. I	2007
Browning, Christopher C. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Pima (Criminal)	1998
Budoff, Robert Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	2000
Burke, Edward O. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	1999
Campoy, Hector E. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Pima (Juvenile)	2000
Chandler, Terry Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Pima (Criminal)	2004
Chavez, Harriett E. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	2003
Chon-Lopez, Javier Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Pima (Juvenile)	2007
Cruikshank, Michael Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Pima (Family)	1998
Davis, Norman J. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Juvenile)	1995
Donahoe, Gary E. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	2000
Duncan, Sally S. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	2004
Fenzel, Alfred M. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Family)	1999
Fink, Dean M. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	2007
Foster Jr., George H. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	2003
Gaines, Pendleton Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	1999
Gama, J. Richard Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	2000
Gemmill, John C. Full Bio Decisions	Meets JPR Standards	View	Appeals Div. I	2001
Grant, Larry Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	2003
Granville, Warren J. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	2000
Hall, Philip Full Bio Decisions	Meets JPR Standards	View	Appeals Div. I	2001
Harrington, Charles V. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Pima (Civil)	1999
Hauser, Brian R. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	1991
Hegyi, Hugh E. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	2007
Heilman, Joseph B Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	1999
Hicks, Bethany G. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	1999
Hoag, M. Jean Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Family)	1996
Hyatt, Carey S. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Family)	2000
Irvine, Patrick Full Bio Decisions	Meets JPR Standards	View	Appeals Div. I	2002
Ishikawa, Brian K. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Juvenile)	1995
Jones, Michael D. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	1995
Kreamer, Joseph C. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	2007
Lee, Raymond Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Juvenile)	2003
Mangum, J. Kenneth Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	1990
Martin, Daniel G. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	2007
Mroz, Rosa P. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	2004
Myers, Samuel J. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	2007
Nichols, Richard D. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Pima (Criminal)	1995
Norris, Benjamin R. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Juvenile)	2008
O'Connor, Karen L. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	2000
Pineda, Susanna C. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	2007
Rayes, Douglas L. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	2000
Rea, John C. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	2004
Reinstein, Peter C. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Family)	1998
Ronan, Emmet J. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	2000
Talamante, David M. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Family)	1999
Thompson, Jon W. Full Bio Decisions	Meets JPR Standards	View	Appeals Div. I	1995
Thumma, Samuel A. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Juvenile)	2007
Verdin, Maria del Mar Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	1999
Warner, Randall H. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Family)	2007
Welty, Joseph C. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Criminal)	2007
Willett, Eileen S. Full Bio	Meets JPR Standards	View	Maricopa (Civil)	1999
Winthrop, Lawrence F. Full Bio Decisions	Meets JPR Standards	View	Appeals Div. I	2002

NOTE:
Judges are evaluated on their judicial performance midway through their term and prior to their retention election. Beginning in 2022, their survey evaluation scores include midterm scores and retention scores. Newly appointed judges serve a two-year term and are evaluated prior to their retention election on their retention scores. The score is the percentage of all evaluators who rated the judge "superior", "very good", or "satisfactory" in each of the Commission's evaluation categories. Depending on the assignment, a judge may not have responses in certain categories, indicated by N/A (for example, some judicial assignments do not require jury trials or no survey responses were returned). The JPR Commission votes "Yes" or "No" on whether a judge "MEETS" Judicial Performance Standards, based on the statistical information, as well as any other information submitted by the public or the judge. Further information on the judges and justices can be found at each court's website.